1.
Number of years together
2.
Distance (miles) between their childhood homes
3.
High school they both attended but didn't meet at
4.
First date was near this local landmark
5.
One of James's funny quirks
6.
Reason for Judy's chest of crafting supplies
7.
James's eastern zodiac sign
8.
Judy's western zodiac sign
9.
Favorite fast-food menu item